Caissie Levy: Balancing Broadway and Motherhood

Embracing the Dual Role: Stage Lights and Family Life

The Daily Juggling Act of a Broadway Star and Mother

When not gracing the stage for eight performances a week, Broadway star Caissie Levy dedicates herself to the everyday routines of family life. Her days are filled with organizing her children's wardrobes, arranging playdates, ensuring they are warmly dressed for the weather with appropriate accessories like hats, gloves, and scarves, and managing at least one load of laundry daily—a practical tip she picked up from social media. Levy admits that while laundry might not always be perfectly folded or immediately put away, it is consistently clean, a small victory in her busy life as both a celebrated performer and a devoted parent.

A Glimpse into a Storied Career and a Heartfelt Choice

Caissie Levy currently captivates audiences as the lead in the critically acclaimed musical 'Ragtime' at Lincoln Center's Vivian Beaumont Theater. Since her Broadway debut in 'Hairspray' in 2004, she has built an impressive resume, famously portraying iconic characters such as Elphaba in 'Wicked' and originating the role of Elsa in 'Frozen'. However, Levy recently made a significant decision to step back from an eagerly anticipated new musical, prioritizing her family's needs. This choice, she reveals, was a challenging yet essential one, prompting an insightful conversation about the complexities of balancing a high-profile career with personal life.

Embodying 'Mother' in the Revival of 'Ragtime'

In 'Ragtime', Levy portrays a character simply known as "Mother," a role that mirrors the evolving dynamics of the American dream at the turn of the 20th century. The musical intricately weaves together the lives of Black Americans in Harlem, white Americans in New Rochelle, and Jewish immigrants on the Lower East Side, showcasing how their paths intertwine and lead to transformative change. Levy notes the heightened emotional impact of 'Ragtime' in today's world, feeling a profound connection to the audience's reactions. Her character, Mother, undergoes significant personal growth, adapting her worldviews as she passionately sings in "Back to Before." Mother's beliefs are challenged and reshaped by unexpected encounters, highlighting her journey of following her conscience, navigating marital changes, redefining her approach to motherhood, and rediscovering her identity as a woman.

Caissie Levy's Personal Act of Selflessness and Insight

Much like her character in 'Ragtime', Caissie Levy faced a moment where her personal and professional life demanded a shift. The intense scrutiny that comes with being a public figure means her career decisions are never taken lightly. When her children, Izaiah (9) and Talulah (4), faced difficulties at the start of the school year, Levy made the difficult but selfless choice to withdraw from a new musical she had been involved with for years, titled 'The Lost Boys'. She describes the decision as heartbreaking and deeply conflicted, explaining that she simply could not be absent from home for the three months required for a new show's opening. In a candid social media post from November 2025, Levy shared her struggles, acknowledging that working parents frequently confront similar agonizing decisions as a part of life's unpredictable journey.

Inspiring a Community of Broadway Mothers

What Levy anticipated would be a disappointing announcement to her fan base, fearing anger or judgment, instead elicited an overwhelming outpouring of support. The sheer volume of kindness from her followers compelled her to temporarily step away from her phone. She expressed surprise at the widespread understanding and resonance with her decision to prioritize family, especially given the rigorous demands of bringing a new Broadway musical to life. The rehearsal process for a new show involves all-day commitments, often ending late, leaving little meaningful time for parents to support their children through challenging phases. Levy revealed that many high-profile Broadway actresses and parents, whom she rarely sees outside of galas or opening nights, reached out, inspired by her video. This viral post, now viewed over 8,000 times, sparked a sense of liberation among her peers, who admitted they had not considered such a choice as an option. Levy found it incredibly rewarding to know that her vulnerability had eased the burden for others, encouraging them to reconsider their own career paths in light of their family commitments.

A Day in the Life: Motherhood Amidst the Spotlight

Freed from the immediate pressure of another new production, Levy has embraced a routine that blends her roles: devoted mother by day, and "Mother" on stage by night, all while managing on about five hours of sleep. A typical day begins early, around 6:30 or 7 AM, when her children often wake her. Mornings are a cherished time for reading, breakfast, and drawing before she drives them to school. After drop-off, her day is a whirlwind of coffee, phone calls, media engagements, and grocery shopping. Meal preparation and lunch packing are duties her husband or babysitter handles, as Levy jokingly admits her culinary skills are not the family's strong suit. Some afternoons allow her to reconnect with her children after school, while other days require her presence in Manhattan by 11 AM for matinee performances, or for appointments such as doctor visits, massages, or vocal massages—all essential for maintaining her demanding vocal and physical condition. She typically returns home between 11:30 PM and 1 AM, depending on the evening's performance schedule. Despite her substantial social media following, Levy enforces a strict no-phone policy when with her family, reserving commute times for responding to texts and emails, and resting her voice. She also enjoys sharing audience responses on Instagram nightly, believing it fosters a sense of community and connection, allowing people to experience and express their emotions through live theater, creating a positive ripple effect.

Cherished Downtime: The Perfect Day Off

For Broadway performers, the single day off typically starts after a Sunday matinee and extends until Tuesday evening's performance. On Sundays, Levy aims to be home in time to tuck her children into bed, cherishing the moments of snuggling with them before spending quality time with her husband. These evenings often involve watching something together or preparing a meal, providing a precious opportunity for conversation and connection. Mondays are dedicated to self-care, with massages or time spent with friends and family. Levy intentionally avoids over-scheduling her day off, preferring to move slowly and relax, a stark contrast to the intense pace of her workweek. After school, she enjoys taking her children to their activities, such as karate or ballet—a rare opportunity during the week. Occasionally, they'll dine out on Monday nights, simply to enjoy each other's company.

The Enduring Wisdom of Motherhood

Levy understands that even when one of her children falls ill, the show must go on. This often means wearing a mask while tending to them, applying Vicks, or comforting them when they are unwell, a necessary precaution to protect her voice and health. She reflects that this resilience and adaptability is a fundamental lesson of parenthood: learning to navigate challenges with grace and make the most of every situation. For now, Caissie Levy finds fulfillment in her dual role as a mother to her own children and as the impactful character "Mother" in 'Ragtime', touching the hearts of audiences and bringing joy and profound satisfaction through her performances.