In a compelling dialogue, Rabbi Angela Buchdahl shares her perspectives on the popular series \u201cNobody Wants This,\u201d particularly its second season, which delves into the nuanced topic of converting to Judaism. She observes that while the show\u2019s ensemble cast, featuring Adam Brody and Kristen Bell, excels in its depiction of various characters\u2014from a rival rabbi to a social media influencer\u2014the central dilemma revolves around Joanne's potential conversion. Buchdahl, notably the first East Asian-American ordained as a rabbi and author of \u201cHeart of a Stranger,\u201d notes that the show has invigorated a sense of pride in contemporary rabbis, rather than directly spurring a wave of conversions. However, she acknowledges a broader trend of increasing interest in Jewish conversion across the country, as evidenced by the growing enrollment in conversion programs at synagogues like her own, which now attract over 300 students annually.
When individuals and couples approach her regarding conversion, several recurring concerns often surface. Prospective converts frequently question whether they will be fully embraced as Jewish, a worry that can be amplified for people of color. Another common apprehension is the fear of never acquiring sufficient knowledge to feel authentically Jewish or of perpetually being labeled as a convert rather than simply Jewish within the community. Buchdahl also addresses the historical understanding that Judaism is not a proselytizing religion, explaining that this stance evolved during periods when Jews lacked sovereignty and security. She posits that when the community feels safe and secure, sharing the richness and meaning of Jewish life with those who might find it valuable becomes a natural inclination, provided it is free from coercion. Furthermore, she critiques \u201cNobody Wants This\u201d for perpetuating outdated stereotypes of Jewish women and a narrow view of who is accepted, particularly the portrayal of a mother rejecting a non-Jewish partner, which she feels does not reflect the more open-minded reality of most Jewish families today. She also expresses disdain for the use of terms like \u201cshiksa,\u201d considering it obsolete.
Despite these criticisms, Buchdahl commends the show for its realistic portrayal of Rabbi Noah, highlighting that he is depicted as a relatable individual with vulnerabilities and aspirations, a refreshing departure from an overly sanctified image. This humanized depiction aligns with the reality that rabbis, unlike some other religious leaders, are often married and have families, underscoring their shared humanity rather than an elevated, holier-than-thou status. This nuanced representation contributes to a more authentic understanding of religious leadership and identity in contemporary society.
Ultimately, this conversation underscores the evolving landscape of religious identity and belonging. It highlights the importance of fostering inclusive communities that embrace individuals on their spiritual journeys, challenging outdated stereotypes and promoting a more nuanced and empathetic understanding of faith in the modern world. The dialogue emphasizes that authenticity and acceptance are crucial for spiritual growth and community strength.