Understanding Online DNA Tests: What You Need to Know Before You Spit

Curiosity about our roots, health predispositions, or even quirky traits has fueled the rise of direct-to-consumer (DTC) online DNA tests. Companies offering these services promise insights gleaned from a simple saliva sample mailed from your home. While these tests offer fascinating possibilities, it's crucial to understand what they can and cannot deliver, especially for the consumers who want to test DNA online.

What Online DNA Tests Can Offer:

1. Ancestry and Genealogy: This remains the most popular and generally most accurate application. Tests analyze markers across your genome to estimate your ethnic origins and connect you with potential genetic relatives (if you opt into matching databases). This can provide valuable clues for building family trees.
2. Trait Reports: Many tests offer reports on harmless inherited characteristics like hair texture, taste preferences (e.g., cilantro aversion), or earwax type, based on well-understood genetic variants.
3. Limited Health Predisposition Insights (FDA-Authorized): Some companies, like 23andMe, offer specific health-related reports that have been reviewed and authorized by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA). These reports cover predispositions (not diagnoses) for a limited number of conditions like certain genetic carrier statuses (e.g., cystic fibrosis, sickle cell anemia), late-onset Alzheimer's disease (APOE variant), or Parkinson's disease. Crucially, these are probabilistic estimates, not certainties.
4. Raw Data Access: Most companies provide you with access to your raw genetic data file. You can download this file, though interpreting it requires significant expertise. Some third-party services offer analysis, but their accuracy and validity are often unregulated.

Important Limitations and Considerations:

5. Not Diagnostic: DTC tests are NOT medical diagnostic tools. They cannot definitively tell you if you have, or will develop, a disease. They primarily indicate increased or decreased relative risk compared to the average population based on known genetic markers. Many complex diseases involve numerous genes, environmental factors, and lifestyle choices not captured by these tests.

6. Limited Scope: Even health-related DTC tests only screen for a tiny fraction of known genetic variants associated with disease. A negative result does not guarantee you are risk-free. A positive result does not mean you will develop the condition.

7. Accuracy and Interpretation: While the genotyping technology is generally reliable for the markers it tests, interpreting the results, especially for health risks, is complex. Results can be:

• Difficult to Understand: Reports often provide relative risk percentages that can be confusing without context.
• Incomplete: They don't consider your full family history, lifestyle, or other non-genetic risk factors.
• Potentially Anxiety-Inducing: Unexpected results about health risks can cause significant worry.

8. Privacy Concerns: This is paramount. Genetic data is uniquely personal and sensitive.

• Company Policies: Carefully read the company's privacy policy. Understand how your data is stored, used (e.g., for internal research, shared with third parties?), and anonymized. Who owns your data once you submit it?
• Security Risks: Any database can be vulnerable to hacking. Consider the potential long-term implications of having your genetic information exposed.
• Third-Party Sharing: Be extremely cautious about uploading your raw data to unregulated third-party interpretation services. Their privacy practices may be less stringent.
• Law Enforcement Access: Databases have been used by law enforcement in criminal investigations (e.g., identifying suspects through relative matching). Companies have differing policies on compliance with law enforcement requests.
• GINA and Insurance: The Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) protects against discrimination in health insurance and employment based on genetic information for most people. However, GINA does NOT cover life insurance, long-term care insurance, or disability insurance. Companies offering these types of insurance could potentially request or use genetic information.

9. Psychological Impact: Results, especially concerning health risks or unexpected family relationships (e.g., undisclosed adoption, misattributed paternity), can be emotionally challenging.

Making an Informed Decision in the US:

10. Define Your Goal: Are you primarily interested in ancestry, or are you seeking health insights? Be honest about your expectations.

11. Research Companies Thoroughly:

• FDA Authorization: If interested in health reports, confirm which specific reports are FDA-authorized for that company.
• Privacy Policy: Scrutinize it. Look for transparency on data usage, storage, sharing (especially with pharma partners or researchers), deletion options, and law enforcement policies. Opt out of research participation if you are uncomfortable.
• Security Measures: What does the company claim to do to protect your data?
• Database Size: Larger databases (especially for ancestry) generally yield more relative matches.

12. Consider Genetic Counseling: Before taking a test with health components, and especially after receiving unexpected or concerning health-related results, consult a qualified genetic counselor or healthcare professional. They can help you understand the results in the context of your personal and family history, discuss implications, and recommend appropriate next steps or confirmatory clinical testing if needed.

13. Understand the Limitations: Accept that these tests provide probabilities and pieces of a puzzle, not definitive answers about your future health.

14. Protect Your Data: Use strong, unique passwords. Be very cautious about sharing your raw data. Consider using a pseudonym if allowed, though this may limit relative matching.

View Now

The Bottom Line:

Online DNA tests offer a powerful window into your genetic heritage and can provide some interesting, FDA-authorized health insights. However, they are not crystal balls or substitutes for medical care. For consumers, the decision to take a test should be made with careful consideration of the limitations, potential psychological impacts, and significant privacy implications. Thorough research into company practices and consultation with a genetic counselor for health-related testing are essential steps towards making a responsible and informed choice. Knowledge is power, but it must be coupled with understanding and caution when it comes to your unique genetic code.